|






















| |
|
RANK |
NAME |
LOCATION |
RECOMMENDATION |
EATING TEAM
INSIGHTS |
|
1 |
Nifty Fifty’s Restaurant |
Multiple Locations |
Black and white
milkshake |
Nifty Fifty’s
Restaurant |
|
2 |
Tanner’s Brothers Dairy |
Ivyland, PA |
Milkshake |
Tanner Brothers Dairy |
|
3 |
Penn State Creamery |
State College, PA |
Any |
|
|
4 |
Rice to Riches |
New York, NY |
Rice Pudding |
Rice to Riches |
|
5 |
Dairy Cottage |
Springfield, PA |
Milkshake |
Dairy Cottage |
|
6 |
Cannoli’s |
Bristol, PA |
Gelato milkshake
|
|
|
7 |
C & C Ice Cream |
Feasterville, PA |
Soft serve |
|
|
8 |
Dairy Delite |
Levittown, PA |
Hot Fudge Sunday |
|
|
9 |
Rita’s Water Ice |
Chain |
Anything |
|
|
10 |
Chink’s Steaks |
Philadelphia, PA |
Black and white
milkshake |
|
|
11 |
Cold Stone Creamery |
Chain |
Any |
|
|
12 |
Gerenser’s |
New Hope, PA |
Any |
|
|
13 |
Kohr Bros Frozen Custard |
Wildwood, NJ |
Soft serve |
Kohr Bros Frozen Custard |
|
14 |
Gibby’s |
Levittown, PA |
Soft serve |
|
|
15 |
Dairy Queen |
Chain |
Blizzards, milkshakes |
|
|
16 |
Carvel |
Chain |
Fudgie the Whale,
Cookiepuss |
|

There are a
couple of shout outs we would like to give to places that aren’t in business
anymore:
1. Greenwood
Dairies – Penndel, PA. Who didn’t at one time try to eat a pig’s dinner!
2. Goodnoe’s
– Newtown, PA. Even though it was in “rich/snobville USA", they still had
great ice cream
-
Cold Stone -
Chocolate ice cream, Bananna ice cream with a brownie is S. Kelly's Favorite.
He wants Coldstone to name it after him. Then again, if it becomes one
of their named creations it will cost him an extra $.50 to a $1.00.
-
As you can see
we are a little short on our list, if you have a local ice cream parlor that
you think belongs on our list, let us know, we are looking for places to
add, that’s what summer is all about!!
|